Home > Ask Our Experts > Can I Reject an Out of Court Settlement after Accepting it?

Can I Reject an Out of Court Settlement after Accepting it?

By: Garry Crystal - Updated: 7 May 2017 | comments*Discuss
 
Can I Reject An Out Of Court Settlement After Accepting It?

Q.25 years ago I was injured in an industrial accident. I was offered some money by way of compensation by the company responsible which I accepted out of court.

Unfortunately, what no one at the time realised was that I had suffered brain damage and was also suffering from undiagnosed Post Traumatic Stress Disorder. I was not in a "sound state of mind" and unable to make a rational decision.

Is my acceptance of this offer legally binding or can I, even at this late stage, have it rejected and thrown out of court due to having experienced mental problems at the time the decision and contract of acceptance was made?
(Mr Peter Steele, 11 September 2008)

A.

Competence of Both Parties

One of the main aspects of a legally binding contract is the competence of both parties who are entering into the contract. An out of court settlement is a legally binding document if both parties have agreed and accepted the terms and conditions of the contract. One of the main points of your question is the “unsound mind” aspect. A contract may not be enforceable if one of the parties was of unsound mind at the time the agreement was entered into. An unsound mind can include mental illness or disability. A person of unsound mind may not have been aware of the terms and conditions and not realised the consequences to the contract they were signing. Employers and businesses will usually settle out of court because it is less expensive for them than going to court. The money offered and accepted at the time may have been a lot less than could have been awarded by going to court. A person suffering from some form of mental illness may not have the capacity to judge whether or not the actual out of court settlement was reasonable and fair. A lawyer or legal representative should have looked over the settlement contract before signing to ensure that the injured party’s rights were intact and that the contract adhered to settlement laws.

Burden of Proof

This out of court settlement may be rescinded by a judge if proof can be found that the injured party was of unsound mind at the time of acceptance. However it may be hard to prove after 25 years that the injured party was of unsound mind at the time. The injured party would need credible witnesses and experts including doctors to support this claim. There may also be time limitations that were written into the out of court settlement’s terms and conditions. A person of unsound mind should have disputed the settlement as soon as possible once they were found to be of sound mind. A contract can be rescinded once the person of unsound mind returns to normal health even if the offering party was unaware of the accepting party’s mental condition when the settlement was offered. In this case, a lawyer will need to prove to the judge that the injured party was of unsound mind when the settlement was made.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
@IA - was the offer of the job dependent upon references? Many jobs are and it may be that your reference has come back unsuitable. There's not much you can do to claim.
Alex - 8-May-17 @ 12:52 PM
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice...
Title:
(never shown)
Firstname:
(never shown)
Surname:
(never shown)
Email:
(never shown)
Nickname:
(shown)
Comment:
Validate:
Enter word:
Latest Comments
  • Emgem
    Re: How a Landlord Agreement Works
    Would this be classed as a breach of tenancy agreement on the landlords part. In the agreement it says pets are not allowed in…
    30 March 2020
  • stone
    Re: Breach of Contract
    I employed a maid to clean and take care of my house to be paid at the end of the month;she worked for two weeks and abandoned the job and…
    17 March 2020
  • Itsme
    Re: Child Maintenance Contracts
    My ex is trying to say that if he is going to see his son then I have to do one drop or pay for one of his lifts? And I have to pay…
    14 March 2020
  • Elaine Yates
    Re: Store Agreements Explained
    Can you pay some money off a Promissory note and then borrow again against the original note For example sign a promissory note for…
    11 March 2020
  • Salpal29
    Re: What If I Don't Have a Written Contract With My Employer?
    My partner now, has a self employed oral agreement with his employer. He has worked there…
    2 February 2020
  • Rose
    Re: The Law & Verbal Agreements
    My daughter and husband bought a house with a small building plot within the boundary that was retained by the seller to build…
    28 January 2020
  • Art
    Re: Legally Binding Contracts
    I took admission for one of the beauty course in private beauty salon in London and paid half fees at the beaning and after a month…
    28 January 2020
  • Ghibli
    Re: How a Landlord Agreement Works
    Landlord changing locks and not supplying a key or emergency or temporary accomadation. This after a fire and after the fire…
    26 January 2020
  • alfie
    Re: Title Deeds: Who Keeps Them?
    no point posting questions here nobody answers!
    24 January 2020
  • Husein
    Re: Contracts and Self Employment
    I am a self employed and working in Amazon last 6 month as delivery driver through RAM distribution Company.Unexpected called me…
    10 January 2020