Home > Case Studies > Breach of Contract - Supplying Food to Allergy Sufferer

Breach of Contract - Supplying Food to Allergy Sufferer

By: Lorna Elliott LLB (hons), Barrister - Updated: 2 Oct 2012 |
 
Breach Of Contract - Supplying Food To Allergy Sufferer

A Sikh couple went to a wedding party held in August 2003. Mr. Bhamra, a research chemist, and his wife had travelled from Birmingham to Forest Gate in London to the Sikh wedding at the Ramgarhia Temple. Mr. Bhamra was allergic to eggs, and knew of his allergy. Egg allergies only affect 0.1% of the population, but as Sikhs do not eat eggs he considered that any of the food he would have eaten was safe. Eggs are strictly forbidden at Sikh temples, and the caterer knew this.

The Extra Food

Unfortunately, more people attended the wedding than had been expected, and as the guests swelled to over five hundred in number, the caterer realised that he was going to have to bring in extra food. The caterer, who was also a Sikh, sent out for extra supplies from external sources. One of the dishes supplied was ‘ras malai’, which is a dessert made of sugary balls of paneer soaked in clotted cream. The recipe for the dessert that was supplied, after the food began to run short, contained eggs.

The Allergic Reaction

Mr. Bhamra ate some of the ras malai, and had an allergic reaction. Although he had been prescribed adrenalin pens in the event of a reaction, he had not brought them with him to the wedding. He collapsed, fell into a coma and was admitted to hospital where he died three days later. He was forty nine years old. The case was brought on the basis of negligence:
  • that the caterer knew that no one would have expected any of the food would have contained eggs
  • that as the caterer he should have known that if he used external food suppliers some recipes for ras malai contained eggs

The County Court Case

The caterer who had supplied the ras malai denied that he had used another supplier to supply extra food. The court of appeal, however, found that he had done exactly this. The court also found that as a caterer he was aware that some recipes for ras malai contained eggs, but that it was not necessary for him to have issued warnings to the wedding guests because so few of the population suffer from the allergy. Some Sikh sects are vehemently against the consumption of meat and eggs, although they do eat milk, butter and cheese. The allergy sufferer had therefore been entitled to feel that there would not be any eggs in the food that was supplied at the wedding.

The Court of Appeal Case

The court of appeal upheld the original judgment at Oxford County Court, which was that the caterer was ordered to pay damages in the sum of £415,000 for negligently supplying food that contained eggs. As the caterer had appealed and because of the delay in time from the original incident to the court of appeal hearing, interest was awarded in the sum of £35,000.

Caterers, and others supplying services and goods to the public, have a duty of care to those that consume their products. This case highlights what can go wrong when that duty of care is not properly observed.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
Why not be the first to leave a comment for discussion, ask for advice or share your story...

If you'd like to ask a question one of our experts (workload permitting) or a helpful reader hopefully can help you... We also love comments and interesting stories

Title:
(never shown)
Firstname:
(never shown)
Surname:
(never shown)
Email:
(never shown)
Nickname:
(shown)
Comment:
Validate:
Enter word:
Latest Comments
  • She
    Re: The Law & Verbal Agreements
    In 2003 my husband had me sign some financial papers one morning. I was running late for work and took no notice, just signing…
    16 September 2020
  • She
    Re: The Law & Verbal Agreements
    In 2003 my husband had me sign some financial papers one morning. I was running late for work and took no notice, just signing…
    16 September 2020
  • Zee
    Re: Illegal Employment Contracts
    I'm working for a community radio station.been with the station for almost 5 years being a Receptionist,working from 9am to…
    13 September 2020
  • Bean
    Re: Title Deeds: Who Keeps Them?
    How do you go about finding the details of a property from the land registry.
    5 September 2020
  • abdul
    Re: Legally Binding Contracts
    I purchased a house in 1992 and made sales agreement and took mortgage for the house. It was bought from distant relative who were…
    26 August 2020
  • Osk
    Re: Contracts and Self Employment
    Hi I’m self employed and have been working part time for the same company for 4 years. I pay my own tax and n.i However - My…
    24 August 2020
  • Sammy
    Re: Agency Work & Contracts
    I work for agency and recently i had to go on medical leave due to the need for hand surgery. I was released from my doctor to go…
    14 August 2020
  • Charlie
    Re: The Law & Verbal Agreements
    I had a verbal agreement with some neighbours to my business address to allow me to place a sign on their fence. I offered…
    7 August 2020
  • Lazyla
    Re: Breach of Contract
    I ordered a custom made cnc in April 2020 on a 14 eta of delivery...3 months down the line after paying in full the bloke now says the quote he…
    29 July 2020
  • Tricky
    Re: Store Agreements Explained
    What was the reply to Carol and happy new year query above?
    27 July 2020