Home > Case Studies > Breach of Contract Against Employer : A Case Study

Breach of Contract Against Employer : A Case Study

By: Lorna Elliott LLB (hons), Barrister - Updated: 26 Jan 2017 |
 
Breach Contract Case Employer Tribunal

Mrs Bryne was sacked as a human resources director of a drug company in January 2001, two months before giving birth. She had complained that male directors were paid more than female directors in the company. This was based on the fact that on promotion from human resources manager to director she had expected a pay rise in line with the other four directors. In fact, she was awarded a pay increase that brought her salary to £52,500.

All of the other directors, who were men, were earning more than £60,000 each. One such director, the finance director, had been given a 36.8% pay rise when he became a director, which meant that his pay was £65,000. Mrs. Bryne sent a memo to her boss highlighting the differences and was told that she ‘wanted too much too soon’ and that she should have ‘ignored what other people were earning.’

The Claim

Mrs. Bryne brought her claim for breach of contract and for sexual discrimination because her boss made a comment that all women who were of child-bearing age should be sterilized. She was sacked after sending the memo and only given three months’ notice rather than the six months to which she was entitled under her contract. This resulted in her not being able to claim for unfair dismissal.

At the Tribunal

Another employee confirmed the boss’s comment about female sterilisation, adding that she was told that if she wanted to progress in her career with the company it was best never to get pregnant. When Mrs. Bryne was recruited, the recruitment consultant was asked to find out whether she intended to start a family or not. She told the tribunal that she was shocked to be asked this question, which is not something that should be asked during the recruitment process or at all by an employer. The recruitment consultant told her that if she brought up the subject of having children, she should reassure her future employers that she was not planning on ‘running off and having millions of babies.’

The tribunal found that the way in which she had been dismissed after sending her boss the email about her salary did constitute unfair dismissal. This was because she would have been entitled to claim damages if she had been given the notice period that was contracted.

The boss in question stated that he liked to crack jokes and to make the working environment less serious. He did however state that he realised that the quip he had made in this instance had been severely off-key. He told the tribunal that he regretted making the remark, and said that it was ‘so grotesque that it could not actually be his opinion.

The Tribunal's Findings

Mrs. Bryne’s sexual discrimination claim was dismissed at the employment tribunal. The tribunal chairman said that the comment made by the boss was just part of the humour that was used in the pharmaceutical industry, and that it did not constitute the boss’s view or that of the company. Mrs. Bryne was awarded damages for successfully proving breach of contract.

Although Mrs. Bryne’s sexual discrimination claim failed, she did receive an award of damages for the breach of contract by her employer.

You might also like...
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice..
I invited by a CEO of a Construction Co, He saw my background related to his need and offered me a job by next day he he told me to do my certifications and given me the facility to come to office and start my certifications, he told me also to send me some other places for practical certification, and finally after 4 days I completed my whole certificates, and every day I was updating him, at meantime he became disappear and now he is not not replying my phone, Msg, and emails, Even he sent me the job descriptions, and I was at his office for some days, and did some clerical works to him, finally he wasted my two weeks time, and kept me out , Plz let me know what to do Now, ??? Date: 01/26/2017
AhJan - 26-Jan-17 @ 5:22 PM
Can you dismiss an employee who has under two years service, without havinglots of meeting. but just one stating why - clash of personality, conduct. whilst off sick.
joshua - 14-Sep-14 @ 4:38 PM
Share Your Story, Join the Discussion or Seek Advice...
Title:
(never shown)
Firstname:
(never shown)
Surname:
(never shown)
Email:
(never shown)
Nickname:
(shown)
Comment:
Validate:
Enter word:
Latest Comments
  • Gwen
    Re: The Law & Verbal Agreements
    I was renting an adjacent paddock to mine from a neighbour and had to replace dangerous fencing between my field, garden and…
    13 June 2019
  • Flower
    Re: Legally Binding Contracts
    My buissnes partner made me sighn a 50 50 joint ownership when I was majority shareholder how do I stand?
    12 June 2019
  • dibzy
    Re: The Law & Verbal Agreements
    after a verbal agreement with my cusion that my mother could be buried with her sister in law (she died 31 years ago ) my…
    10 June 2019
  • MTri
    Re: Gym Contracts Explained
    I'm a member at my local gym, where they require 2 months notice before leaving it. I recently cancelled my direct debit because I'd…
    8 June 2019
  • rachelgreen
    Re: The Law & Verbal Agreements
    Wonderful article on business which are one of the most common & convenient short-term business that are during financial…
    3 June 2019
  • Rana
    Re: Unfairness in Contracts
    on 9/3/2019 I phone sky to find out price for sports package for a small bar. I was told it would be about £1017 per month. I said that…
    12 May 2019
  • Rana
    Re: Unfairness in Contracts
    on 9/3/2019 I phone sky to find out price for sports package for a small bar. I was told it would be about £1017 per month. I said that…
    12 May 2019
  • S'DUMO
    Re: Title Deeds: Who Keeps Them?
    I HAVE PAID MY HOUSE IN FULL THAT WAS 2012,WHEN I WAS RETRENCHED FROM MY PREVIOUS JOB.I WASN'T TOLD WHEN I PAID THE HOUSE IN FULL…
    9 May 2019
  • trish
    Re: What Are T.U.P.E Claims?
    we were tuped just over 2 years ago and have heard that the new employer is now selling the business. staff have been told nothing by…
    8 May 2019
  • Djs210664
    Re: Contracts and Self Employment
    I have worked as a self employed operations manager for 2 years 5 months 5 days a week 40 hours a week and I have just been told…
    5 May 2019